Compensation Benchmarks for Nonprofits
Nonprofit compensation data, from IRS Form 990 filings
Your mission runs on its people. Pay them with confidence.
See what similar nonprofits pay, from the executive director to the front line, drawn from IRS Form 990 filings and federal wage data and fitted to your budget, sector and location.
Board member? Start with the Board Report. Setting pay for every role? See Professional. Using Claude or ChatGPT? Connect CauseComp.
| Organization | Location | Form 990 year | Total comp |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1Harbor Light Community Trust | Chicago, IL | 2024 | $229,900 |
| 2Northfield Care Alliance | Evanston, IL | 2025 | $226,600 |
| 3Emberline Community Works | Naperville, IL | 2024 | $222,500 |
| 4Prairie Bridge Collective | Peoria, IL | 2025 | $212,400 |
| 5Broadleaf Family Partners | Rockford, IL | 2025 | $211,300 |
Modeled range: P25 $179,550 · P75 $223,440.
Figures are as filed by default, or aged to any date you choose.
Illustrative sample. Fictional organizations and figures. A subscriber's set is drawn from public Form 990 filings for the role, budget size, sector and state entered.
What should our next Executive Director earn at a human-services nonprofit in Illinois like ours?
Modeled median $199,500, with a modeled range of P25 $179,550 to P75 $223,440. That median falls within the pay range of the 20 named peers.
Source: CauseComp executive benchmark · IRS Form 990 filings
Illustrative sample. Fictional organizations and figures. The connector is included with Professional.
Choose your starting point
-
Board Report
Executive pay, with named peers
$349 one time.
See the Board Report -
Essential
For teams that benchmark Workforce and executive pay.
$49/month, adds on to a Board Report. $499/year.
See Essential -
Professional
Unlimited board reports and every role, with the Claude and ChatGPT connector included.
$99/month, adds on to a Board Report. $999/year.
See ProfessionalTry Professional free for 7 days
New: the 2026 Nonprofit Compensation Report, built from Form 990 filings.
Read the reportAsk your AI about nonprofit pay and it estimates. Ask it with CauseComp connected and it answers from Form 990 filings.
The figures, data vintage and disclaimer come from CauseComp, not the model.
Included in Professional. See how the connector works
Illustrative sample
What should our next Executive Director earn at a human-services nonprofit in Illinois like ours?
Asked CauseComp for the executive benchmark
Modeled median $199,500; P25 $179,550 to P75 $223,440.
Source: CauseComp executive benchmark, IRS Form 990 filings
Which Illinois nonprofits did that compare us with?
Asked CauseComp for the comparables set
20 named peers, from their Form 990 filings. The three highest paid:
- Harbor Light Community Trust, Chicago, IL: $229,900
- Northfield Care Alliance, Evanston, IL: $226,600
- Emberline Community Works, Naperville, IL: $222,500
Source: CauseComp comparables set, IRS Form 990 filings
Our board is considering $199,500. Where does that sit?
Asked CauseComp for the modeled benchmark and the comparables set
$199,500 falls within the pay range of the 20 named peers and inside the modeled range of $179,550 to $223,440.
Source: CauseComp executive benchmark and comparables set, IRS Form 990 filings
Fictional organizations and figures.
Your 990 asks how you set executive pay. The answer is public.
Form 990, Part VI, line 15 asks whether your process for setting executive pay used independent review, comparability data and documentation made at the time.
Under the intermediate sanctions rules (IRC §4958), the regulation sets three conditions for a presumption that pay is reasonable: advance approval by an independent body, reliance on comparability data, and documentation made at the time. CauseComp supplies the comparability data and the documentation of how it was drawn.
Data like this supports, but does not by itself establish, a board's rebuttable presumption of reasonableness under IRC §4958 (intermediate sanctions), which also requires advance approval by an independent board body and contemporaneous documentation. CauseComp provides comparability data for informational purposes and does not provide legal or tax advice.
Built by a compensation consultant.
CauseComp was built by the founder of RB Consulting Services, a career executive compensation consultant. For complex packages, multi-entity organizations, board disputes or IRS inquiries, a compensation consultant can take it from there.
Modeled, not averaged, and documented in the open.
Describe the role.
Position, budget size, state or metro, sector.
Get your benchmark.
Percentiles calibrated to organizations like yours, not a national average.
Take it to the board.
Excel exports and board-ready PDFs on Professional, with the methodology documented on every page.
Answers before you sign up.
We're a small nonprofit. Do we need a subscription?
Not always. It depends on how often you'll need an answer. Professional is $999/year and covers unlimited board reports, workforce benchmarks across 850+ roles, and executive estimates modeled to your budget size, sector, and location. If you have exactly one position to document and don't expect to look again, buy the one-time Board Report ($349) instead. Your $349 counts toward Professional annual if you upgrade within 90 days.
How current are the numbers?
The underlying filings and surveys refresh on their federal publication cycles, and we refresh our data quarterly. Every report shows its data vintage.
Is this a substitute for a compensation consultant?
CauseComp gives you the same data foundation a consultant would use, and for many organizations that's all they need. It isn't professional advice, and for complex situations we'll tell you honestly when you need a professional.
Is my data confidential?
We never sell your queries or organization details, and we never share them with other customers. We do use a small set of service providers to run CauseComp (payment, email, analytics and error monitoring), each handling only what it needs to; they are described in our Privacy Policy. Benchmarks are built from public filings and federal surveys.